well poisoning

Tainting drinking sources

Well poisoning is a rhetorical tactic of preemptively discrediting a source or argument before it can be heard: He poisoned the well by calling her a liar before she could testify.

The metaphor comes from the medieval accusation—often directed at Jews—of literally contaminating water supplies.

The phrase names a logical fallacy: attacking credibility to prevent fair evaluation of evidence.

Related

Black Death · conspiracy · blood libel · false accusation · plague · aquifer · toxic · murder · foul play · groundwater · accusation · scapegoat · persecution · witch hunt · cyanide · cholera · sabotage · paranoia

Categories
Opposites
intent toward community resources

well poisoningwater purification

Rendering liquid safe to drink

water treatment · well digging · watershed protection · water sanitation

rhetorical/argumentative strategy

well poisoningfair hearing

Impartial consideration of evidence

fair representation · epistemic humility

social trust and community action

well poisoningcommunal care

Shared responsibility for wellbeing

collective welfare · mutual aid · public service

Family

well, wells, welled, welling, poison, poisons, poisoned, poisoning, poisoner

Familiarity
Top 500,000
Profile
Used worldwide · Timeless · Concrete · Negative · Everyday, not technical · Rated PG-13