close, but no cigar

Nearly got it

Close, but no cigar acknowledges a near miss—an attempt that came close to succeeding but ultimately failed.

The phrase alludes to carnival games that once awarded cigars as prizes: You almost had the answer—close, but no cigar.

It softens disappointment with a touch of encouragement, recognizing effort while noting it fell short.

Related

failure · tantalizingly · shortfall · attempt · prize · carnival · game · swing · strike · effort · disappointment · tough break · narrow · inch · hairbreadth · runner-up · second place · second best

Opposites
SUCCESS vs. NEAR-MISS

close, but no cigarbullseye

Exact center target

bingo · nailed it · hit the nail on the head · spot on · winner

degree of failure

close, but no cigarnot even close

Extremely inaccurate assessment

way off · nowhere near · miles away · wide of the mark · struck out

Family

close, closed, closer, closest, closely, closeness, closing, closure, enclose

Familiarity
Top 100,000
Profile
Mostly American · Timeless · Everyday, not technical · Rated G