had one's cake and ate it too

Kept both options

Had one's cake and ate it too describes getting two benefits that normally exclude each other—enjoying something while also preserving it.

The phrase captures impossible greed or improbable success: She wanted to quit her job and keep the salary—have her cake and eat it too.

Usually appears with want or can't: You can't have your cake and eat it too.

Related

paradox · proverbs · expectations · impossibility · contradiction · entitlement · wishful thinking · ambition · privilege · duality · burning the candle · trade off · regret · satisfaction · colloquialisms · self-interest · fairness · inconsistency

Opposites
outcome fairness and trade-offs

had one's cake and ate it toopaid the price

Suffered deserved consequences

bit the bullet · robbed Peter to pay Paul

greed vs. acceptance

had one's cake and ate it toocut one's losses

Exit a bad situation

picked one's battles

outcome fairness

had one's cake and ate it toosplit the difference

Agree on midpoint amount

paid one's dues

Family

had, have, has, having, hath, one, ones, cake, cakes

Familiarity
Top 200,000
Profile
Known to kids · Used worldwide · Timeless · Everyday, not technical · Rated G