you must be joking

Related

surely · impossible · disbelief · sarcasm · incredulous · eyebrow · laughter · absurd · really · skeptical · shocked · stunned · pulling my leg · no way · are you serious · outrageous · scoff · mock

Opposites
sincerity/seriousness

you must be jokingof course

Expression of obvious agreement

no kidding · naturally · that figures · obviously · fair enough

emotional valence of reaction

you must be jokingcongratulations

Expression of praise for achievement

fantastic · brilliant · count me in · absolutely

emotional register

you must be jokingfine

Acceptable in quality

so be it · noted · understood · very well · I see

Familiarity
Top 2,000,000