There are gender wars, and then there are casualties. It wasn’t until 2011 that the behemoth toymaker LEGO acknowledged girls’ desire to build with bricks, even though the company had long before made a seemingly effortless pivot to co-branding, video games, and major motion pictures. So it’s little wonder that girls face all-too-real obstacles when […] […]Read more
IDEA is in the planning stages of a new project, to create a new thesaurus app for the iPad. As an experiment, we investigated whether “crowd funding” is a viable way to fund new educational apps. Our Kickstarter project was not funded, but we are still making the app!
Here’s some information about our Kickstarter experiment.
What is KickStarter?
KickStarter is a way to fund creative projects. They contributed $67 million to arts projects in 2011, and are on track to distribute more money to the arts in 2012 than the National Endowment for the Arts.
Individuals and organizations post a project, set a target budget, create a pitch video, define rewards, and hope enough people will pledge to back their project. Only fully-backed projects are funded. This all-or-nothing approach helps backers pledge with the confidence that they will only pay if enough other people also support the project.
Our KickStarter experiment
We posted a project to create a visual thesaurus app. (Preview at right.) The premise of our project was to raise funds to cover most of the development costs, and then release the app inexpensively or free. Free apps tend to be downloaded 10x-100x more than paid apps, even more so for educational content.
The time commitment was approximately 9 days. Of that, 5 days were spent on initial designs and mockups for our app idea; 2 days to write and revise a script, and produce the promo video; a day to plan and write up the KickStarter project page, and a day for updates and feedback to backers.
Video production was done using Final Cut Pro, and audio was recorded with a Sennheiser e935 microphone, pop filter, and Focusrite Saffire Pro 14 audio adapter, and edited using Adobe SoundBooth and Peak Pro. The royalty-free music was found at SoundCloud.
Educational apps are stagnating relative to the overall explosion of mobile devices. Current challenges stifling educational apps include:
- Weak economics – Aside from mobile textbooks (which are required purchases by school districts), kids, parents, and teachers are slow to pay for educational apps. The market of consumers who will pay $5 or $10 for an educational app is small. Funding has to come from other places.
- Hard to make – Good educational apps require an expensive microcosm of skills, from content development and outreach, to user interface design and programming. Existing educational industries (e.g., publishing, museums) do not have the expertise to select and manage teams who make apps.
- Fear of cannibalism – As budgets shrink, institutions are afraid of giving away too much for free. It’s a disgrace that massive back catalogues of educational content, videos, and object collections are not already online and in apps.
- Poor funding models – Since apps are costly to produce, app publishers typically need either grant funding, a large financial upside to justify self-funding or investor-backing… or … maybe crowd-funding?
Is it appropriate for apps?
Our experience is no. The following is a graph of our funding, which shows initial growth in the first few days (it’s very exciting to have strangers back your project!), followed by flatlining funding despite coverage in five education/technology blog articles, 51 FaceBook “likes,” and over 180 followers on Twitter for this new project.
Our observation is that Kickstarter backers tend to be drawn to creative projects like new music albums or engineering projects (e.g., a new iPod dock or gadget), not to philanthropic-like projects. The promise of our project was to reduce the end-user price of an educational app, a proposition which was not appealing. Conversely, the pool of educators reached by blog coverage of our project were willing to retweet, but not to send their own money to back it.
Our Kickstarter is archived, and you can still see it. This was a worthwhile experiment in that it was an opportunity to build publicity about a new project, think about the value proposition of the project, and flesh out some early designs, but I would not recommend it to other app developers.
Updated 14-April-2012 with results of Kickstarter.